top of page
Search
Long Island waterfront home with a private dock, bulkhead, and boat

Buying Waterfront on Long Island: What to Verify About the Dock and Bulkhead Before Closing

Taub and Bogaty
Nov 1
5 min read
Long Island waterfront home with a private dock, bulkhead, and boat

Taub & Bogaty, PLLC | realestatelawny.com | (516) 531-2500


On a Long Island waterfront home, the dock, bulkhead, floats, and boat lift are part of what you are buying. Each of those structures sits in space regulated by one or more government bodies, and each has a permit history worth reading before you buy. Ideally, the checking starts before the contract is signed and continues through the title, survey, and closing review. The questions are whether every structure was lawfully built, what condition it is in, and who owns the bay bottom under it.


The Agencies With a Say Over the Structure


The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation regulates tidal wetlands and the adjacent areas around them, which can extend up to 300 feet inland from the wetland boundary, depending on site conditions. Under the Tidal Wetlands Act, DEC requires a permit for almost any activity that alters those areas, and its list of regulated construction includes docks, piers, catwalks, boat slips, bulkheads, sea walls, decks, and pools. Federal authorization may also be required from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which regulates structures such as docks, piers, and bulkheads in or over navigable waters under Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act, and the discharge of dredged or fill material under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act. A Corps permit may be required whether or not DEC requires one.


The town or village where the property sits may have its own requirements as well. On Long Island, one more question sits beneath all of these: who owns the land under the water.


Who Owns the Bay Bottom Under the Dock


Where the State of New York owns the underwater land, Section 75 of the Public Lands Law requires a lease, easement, permit, or other interest from the Office of General Services before a dock, pier, platform, mooring, or similar structure can be built, substantially replaced, altered, or enlarged over it. The statute provides for an exception covering certain noncommercial structures built before June 17, 1992, and whether a particular dock qualifies is a question to settle with documents.


In some Long Island towns, colonial patents created town ownership or trustee rights in underwater lands. Southampton, for example, traces those rights to the 1686 Dongan Patent, and its Town Trustees oversee common underwater lands and list inspecting structures built on bay bottom among their responsibilities. Where a town's trustees hold the bottom, a dock over it may need their authorization. Whether a particular stretch of bottom is state-owned, town-controlled, or privately held under a grant is a title question.


What Makes a Structure Lawfully Existing


DEC's tidal wetlands permit requirement applies to new regulated activity on or after August 20, 1977, and its regulations protect structures lawfully in existence on that date from removal under those rules. A dock that was lawfully in existence on that date may have no DEC tidal wetlands permit on file and still qualify as lawfully existing. Continuing a lawfully existing use that leaves the land, the wetland, and the existing structures unchanged requires no tidal wetlands permit, and DEC draws that line narrowly. Replacing broken boards on a functional dock requires no tidal wetlands permit. Changing the dock's length, width, or position does. Work on a structure that has deteriorated to the point it no longer functions falls outside the exemption entirely.


Whether a bulkhead is functional and lawfully existing is among the key eligibility questions under DEC's general permit for bulkhead replacement in Nassau and Suffolk counties, an alternative to an individual permit for bulkheads that qualify. That general permit states that docks, decks, boat lifts, and floats that are not lawfully existing will not be legalized through it and are subject to possible DEC legal action. A dock or bulkhead built without the required permits, or one that has decayed past use, may need an individual permit before it can be repaired or replaced.


Condition Shapes the Permitting Path


The repair exemption covers functional structures only, so the physical condition of a dock or bulkhead determines which permitting route a future repair will take. An inspection by a qualified marine contractor or engineer before closing tells you what the structure needs and gives your attorney something concrete to work with if the answer affects the price.


What to Request Before Closing


Ask for these as early in the transaction as you can:


  • Every permit issued for each structure, from DEC, the Army Corps, the town or village, and the town trustees or the Office of General Services where they have jurisdiction, along with the approved plans. For a structure built before August 20, 1977, ask for whatever documents establish when it was built.

  • A current survey showing the structures and the water boundary, so you can compare the structures as built against what the permits approved.

  • A condition inspection of the dock and bulkhead.

  • Confirmation of what must be transferred, assigned, reissued, or newly obtained before closing, for each permit and any underwater land authorization. DEC permits are transferable unless a statute, regulation, or permit condition prohibits it. The transfer application requires certification from both the current permittee and the new owner and should generally be submitted at least 30 days before the transfer, so the seller's cooperation is worth securing in the contract.


When the records have gaps, the contract can address them. Depending on what is missing, the options may include a contingency tied to receiving the documentation, a price adjustment or credit, or a requirement that the seller obtain the missing authorization before closing.


Reviewing a Waterfront Purchase With Taub & Bogaty


At Taub & Bogaty, PLLC, we represent buyers in residential purchases across Long Island. We review the contract, the title report, and the survey, and we can write protections into the contract when a structure's records have gaps.


If you are buying a waterfront home, call us at (516) 531-2500 or contact our office online while you are still weighing the offer. Permit questions raised before you sign can shape the contract itself.


Related Reading






Primary Sources


NYS DEC, Tidal Wetlands Permit Program: Do I Need a Permit?: dec.ny.gov


NYS DEC General Permit GP-1-22-001, Bulkhead Replacement with Dredging (Nassau and Suffolk): extapps.dec.ny.gov


6 NYCRR Section 621.11, Permit Renewals, Modifications, and Transfers: law.cornell.edu


NYS DEC, Check Permit Status (permit transfers): dec.ny.gov


U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, New York District Regulatory Program Applicant Information Guide: nan.usace.army.mil


6 NYCRR Section 661.8, Permit Requirements: regulations.justia.com


6 NYCRR Section 661.10, Existing Land Use and Development: regulations.justia.com


NY Public Lands Law Section 75: law.justia.com


NYS Office of General Services, Guidelines for In-Water Structures: ogs.ny.gov


Trustees of the Freeholders and Commonalty of the Town of Southampton v. Grannis (2010): law.justia.com


Town of Southampton, Town Trustees: southamptontownny.gov


 
 
 

Comments


Attorney Advertising: The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. We invite you to contact us and welcome your calls, letters, and electronic mail. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information to us until such time as an attorney-client relationship has been established.

Read Full Disclaimer. This website has been scanned and updated to meet WCAG 2.0 Level AA accessibility compliance.  Read our Accessibility Statement.

Website Created and Maintained by Boxer Media Services Corp.

©2026 Taub & Bogaty PLLC. All Rights Reserved

bottom of page